TOH BHW Comparison Table

American Home Shield Choice Home Warranty Amazon Home Warranty
$50 off for This Old House $50 off + 1 month free $75 off + 1 month free
Visit Site Visit Site Visit Site
Plan options: 4 + optional add-ons 2 + optional add-ons 3 + optional add-ons
Monthly premium: $50–$60 $36–$44 $40–$48
Service fee: $75–$125 $60–85 $75
Recall period: 60 days on parts and labor 90 days on parts 30 days on labor 90 days on parts 30 days on labor
Our rating: Best Overall Best Service Best Add-Ons