The 4 Best 4-Slice Toasters (2021 Review) Scroll ← Conclusion Pros Cons Most sleek Cuisinart Metal Classic Four-Slice Toaster Check Price Our Take Besides its plastic base and controls, this Cuisinart toaster is made entirely of stainless steel for a modern look. Pros – Offers six browning options from light to dark– Offers convenient cord storage– Made of BPA-free material Cons – Priced higher than other toasters in this review– Has the heaviest weight out of the products in this guide at six pounds Best controls Cuisinart Four-Slice Compact Plastic Toaster Check Price Our Take Get the precise shade of toast you want with this toaster’s seven shade levels and bagel, defrost, and reheat settings. Pros – Has large slots that can fit thick slices of bread– Has light-up buttons to indicate which setting is selected– Features a high-lift carriage that works when the toaster is sideways or forward-facing Cons – A couple customers said that the coils overheated– Made of mostly plastic, which is less aesthetically pleasing than stainless steel Elite Gourmet Maxi-Matic Four-Slice Long Toaster Check Price Our Take This toaster from Elite Gourmet takes up less space on your countertop without sacrificing key features, such as adjustable toasting levels and a drop-down crumb tray. Pros – Built with 1.25-inch slots to fit breads of all shapes and sizes– Has a reheat function to warm bread at a lower temperature without burning it– Most economically priced option in this buying guide Cons – Some customers mentioned issues with toasted items landing on the floor– Doesn’t include a bagel function like other models Hamilton Beach Four-Slice Toaster Check Price Our Take This Hamilton Beach toaster keeps safety top of mind with cool-touch sides, an automatic shut-off feature, and a one-push cancel button. Pros – Has wide slots to accommodate bagels and thick breads– Features two knobs that let you customize the shade of your toast– Has a high-lift boost mechanism to reach small slices of bread once they have been toasted Cons – Some customers said that they had to toast their food twice because of uneven browning– Doesn’t have a reheat function like other models
