Best For Monthly Cost BBB Rating Service Fee States Not Covered
American Home Shield Visit site Best Overall $40–$58 B $75–$125 AK
Choice Home Warranty Visit site Best Basic Plan $36–$44 B $60–85 CA, WA
Select Home Warranty Visit site Best Value $36–$38 B $60–$75 NV, NM, WA, WY
American Home Shield
Best For Best Overall
Monthly Cost $40–$58
BBB Rating B
Service Fee $75–$125
States Not Covered AK
Visit Site 844-529-9298
Choice Home Warranty
Best For Best Basic Plan
Monthly Cost $36–$44
BBB Rating B
Service Fee $60–85
States Not Covered CA, WA
Visit Site 929-400-6165
Select Home Warranty
Best For Best Value
Monthly Cost $36–$38
BBB Rating B
Service Fee $60–$75
States Not Covered NV, NM, WA, WY
Visit Site 888-370-3956