| Superlative | Our Reputation Score | Years in Business | Get Quote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Endurance | Best Coverage | 5.0 stars | 14 | Free Quote |
| 2. CARCHEX | Best for Older Vehicles | 5.0 stars | 21 | Free Quote |
| 3. autopom! | Best Customer Service | 4.5 stars | 10 | Free Quote |
| 4. CarShield | Best Budget Warranty | 4.0 stars | 15 | Free Quote |
| 5. Protect My Car | Best Maintenance Contracts | 4.0 stars | 14 | Free Quote |